Humans Have Changed Stingrays’ Ways

Stingrays living in the Cayman Islands' Stingray City, one of the world's most famous and heavily-visited ecotourism sites, have profoundly changed their ways, raising questions about the impact of so-called "interactive ecotourism" on marine wildlife.

Researchers from Nova Southeastern University's Guy Harvey Research Institute and the University of Rhode Island studied the southern stingray population of Stingray City -- which draws nearly a million visitors each year to feed, pet and swim with its stingrays -- to assess how the intensive ecotourism has affected the animals' behavior. "Measuring that impact is important because there's a lot of interest in creating more of these interactive ecotourism operations, but we know little about the life histories of the animals involved or how they might change," said study co-author Guy Harvey, who initiated the project.

The results, published last month in the journal PLOS ONE, found that Stingray City's stingrays show distinctly different patterns of activity than their wild counterparts, who don't enjoy daily feedings or close human contact. "We saw some very clear and very prominent behavioral changes, and were surprised by how these large animals had essentially become homebodies in a tiny area," says study co-author Mahmood Shivji, director of the Guy Harvey Research Institute.

Wild stingrays are active at night and solitary; they forage through the night over large distances to find food, and rarely cross paths with other stingrays. To see if Stingray City's residents stray from this behavior, the research team tagged and monitored both wild and fed stingrays for two years and compared their patterns of movement. They found that fed stingrays swapped their normal nighttime foraging for daytime feeding, and in contrast to their wild counterparts, began to rest at night. They also didn't mind rubbing shoulders with their neighbors. At least 164 stingrays abandoned the species' normal solitary behavior, crowding together in less than a quarter-square-mile of space at Stingray City. They even formed schools and fed together. The fed stingrays mated and became pregnant year-round, instead of during a specific mating season, and also showed signs of unusual aggression, biting each other more frequently than their wild counterparts.

These results suggest that human-provided food can dramatically change how even large, highly mobile ocean animals behave, with potentially serious consequences. "There are likely to be some health costs that come with these behavior changes, and they could be detrimental to the animals' well-being in the long term," Shivji said.

Stingray City means big business in the Cayman Islands, where each stingray generates as much as $500,000 annually in tourism income. The team plans to continue to monitor Stingray City's population to track its health -- and the industry's impact -- over time. "Right now, these animals have no protection at all," Harvey said. "Without more studies like these, we won't know what that means for the wildlife or if we need to take action. It's unclear how much of the stingray's daily diet comes from tourism provided food, but the good news is we have seen the animals forage when tourists are absent, suggesting that these animal are not completely dependent on these handouts."