Police investigating the January disappearance of a
Louisiana couple while they were diving on the Great
Barrier Reef have concluded they died after the charter
boat Outer Edge left them at sea. (See the complete story
in the March Undercurrent.)
Many people in the Aussie diving industry claimed
that Thomas (33) and Eileen Lonergan (28) had faked
their deaths or even committed suicide. One dive
operator claimed that he returned the same day with
three extra divers aboard his boat. A television crew and
a hotel worker claimed to have seen the Lonergans
months after they disappeared.
But police said they discovered no evidence that
the Lonergans invented their deaths and speculated
much of it was a campaign to keep the dive industry in
a good light.
The Lonergans were among the twenty-six divers
and five crew aboard the charter boat Outer Edge. After
the final dive of the day, the boat departed without
them for the forty-plus mile trip back to the mainland.
They did not miss them until two days later, when the
boat crew found some of their gear aboard.
Weeks after their disappearance, a fin with "Eileen
L" printed on the bottom, her BC and wetsuit hood,
and one of their tanks were found washed up on
remote beaches. In July, fishermen found a slate with
the plea "Please help us. Find us soon before we die."
Both signed the message.
True to form, however, the industry organization Dive
Queensland alleged the Lonergans had planted the slate
as part of a fake disappearance. However, police tests and
marine growth showed that the slate was in the water for
several months and it was not a hoax.
During the inquest that took place in Cairns last
month, it was unclear whether a head count had been
taken. A dive instructor who initially told police he did
not take a head count changed his story three days
later. Another said that the head counts were a "very
weak link" in the security chain. "The tourists are
constantly moving around you. They're on holidays,
they're chatting and drinking, wandering around."
It was learned that the crew had ignored two pairs
of shoes left on the dock (the Lonergans) after all the
other passengers had taken theirs (divers remove shoes
before boarding and pick them up afterwards). A bus
driver who was to pick up the Lonergans reported she
had told the Outer Edge captain and owner Jack Nairn
that she couldn't find them. The day after their
disappearance, a diver aboard the Outer Edge returning
to the same reef found six dive weights at the bottom of
the sea and took them to Nairn, who said it was a bonus
to find extra weights and said "you might find a tank or
something out there as well."
The most plausible explanation for their disappearance
came from Ben Cropp, one of Australia's leading
shark experts and divers. Cropp, who has made more
than 10,000 dives in forty-eight years, told the inquest:
"My personal feeling is they were taken by a tiger
(shark) in the first 24 to 48 hours. A tiger given a day
or two...would be a very serious threat. You'd appear
helpless to them. They just circle and watch. They may
do this for an hour before moving closer and may
follow you for another hour before they take that first
bite, and then you don't have a hope because they've
made up their mind. Then the shark would concentrate
on the second person, following them for an hour
or perhaps all night. They're a pretty horrible feeding
machine when they make up their mind."
Cropp said that if a shark did not kill the
Lonergans, then "dehydration and despair" would have
killed them. Officials said they expect manslaughter
charges to be filed.
On another note, in late July the Outer Edge picked
up three divers whose craft had overturned and was
half submerged in rough weather.