On my last trip to Cozumel, besides nurse
sharks and turtles, I didn’t see big critters. But
I saw an eye-popping painted elysia sea slug
looking as fine as the one pictured in Paul
Humann’s Reef Creatures.
When I was a new diver, I was out for the
  big stuff. But after seeing hundreds of barracuda
  and lobsters, I appreciated more diverse
  pleasures in the reef environment.  
That’s where my magnifying glass comes in.
  The tiny shrimp lurking in the lettuce coral,
  the clinging crab in the anemone, and the
  pipefish in the sand flats are easier to ID and
  a lot more spectacular with a good glass. I also
  get a lot more detail on other denizens, including
  the corals.  
 If you want to go small, you need a glass
  lens, not plastic. That’s because the index of
  refraction of water is about 1.33. Plastic lenses
  have about the same index as water, so they
  become useless underwater.
  Optical glass has an index
  of about 1.52, so it works,
  though the magnification
  underwater will be a bit less
  than above.
If you want to go small, you need a glass
  lens, not plastic. That’s because the index of
  refraction of water is about 1.33. Plastic lenses
  have about the same index as water, so they
  become useless underwater.
  Optical glass has an index
  of about 1.52, so it works,
  though the magnification
  underwater will be a bit less
  than above.  
Index of refraction?
  That’s a measure of how much a substance
  slows the speed of light, and thus bends
  (refracts) it. Water’s index of 1.33 also explains
  why objects appear 1/3 larger underwater, and
  why your buddy swears that a 3-foot grouper
  was a 4-footer.  
Magnifying lenses in your mask (bifocals)
  are not very useful for viewing underwater
  subjects except gauges. This goes for the plastic
  stick-on bifocals as well as the Mares ESA mask,
  which has separate lens frames in which you
  can put magnifiers.  
Instead, you need a good hand-held glass.
  I’ve tried several and my favorite is Edmund
  Scientific (www.scientificsonline.com). Look
  for the Round Magnifier With 10X Spot Lens.
  The 4-inch lens (you don’t want a small one
  that you need to hold too close to the subject)
  is available there for $11.95, plus $6.40 for
  shipping. It fits in a BC pocket and has a hole
  in the handle for a lanyard. Happy hunting.  
– M.A.